The Role of Employee Experience in Agile Performance Management

An In-depth Analysis of Peoplelogic’s 3rd Principle of Agile Performance Management

‍

In recent years, the concept of Agile Performance Management (APM) has gained significant traction in organizational management practices. Derived from agile software development, Agile Performance Management aims to create a more flexible, responsive, and employee-centric culture as it pertains to performance management. Recognizing that employee engagement drives overall business success, Agile Performance Management emphasizes adaptability and alignment. 

With this in mind, Peoplelogic designed the 12 Principles of Agile Performance Management to provide a blueprint for organizations seeking to adopt a technology-forward, growth-minded approach to performance management. Among the key principles of APM, Peoplelogic’s third principle, focusing on Employee Experience, stands out as one of the most critical tenants in driving organizational success and employee engagement. This principle emphasizes the importance of creating a positive and engaging work environment that empowers employees to perform at their best. This principle recognizes that traditional performance management systems often fail to consider the employee's perspective, leading to disengagement and reduced productivity. 

Today, employees are signaling the need for a mindset shift when it comes to how goals are set, what gets measured, the level of autonomy and ownership of their work, and the cadence of feedback. By placing Employee Experience at the forefront, APM seeks to align organizational goals with individual aspirations, fostering a more motivated and high-performing workforce. But we can’t talk about motivation and performance without underscoring the psychology of those behaviors and outcomes. 

This article aims to explore the significance of Employee Experience within the context of Agile Performance Management from multiple angles, examining what we know about employee experience, and weaving in the psychology behind employee engagement’s proven impact on organizational performance, employee satisfaction, and overall business outcomes. Let’s dive in!

‍

The Underpinning of Employee Experience

Employee experience can be defined as the holistic perception an employee has of their interactions with an organization throughout their employment journey. This means everything from onboarding to the relationship with their manager, career development to the training and tools they need to be successful in their role. 

In today's competitive business environment, organizations prioritize employee experience metrics such as engagement, productivity, and retention as indicators of effective workforce management. Achieving these metrics hinges on fostering essential sentiments that directly tie to psychology such as trust, belonging, inclusion, fairness, and confidence. These are crucial for enhancing employee experience. While every organization is different, research indicates that a strategic approach to performance management can significantly amplify these sentiments, leading to improved engagement, productivity, and retention. 

This research forces us to further examine the psychology behind engagement and productivity. When we know that employee engagement increases when we implement programs and processes that lend themselves towards the sentiments we want to cultivate, we must pull that thread and go beyond traditional approaches to managing performance and engagement. 

‍

The Psychology of the Employee Experience

Psychology is the scientific study of the mind and behavior, examining mental processes like thoughts, feelings, and motivations, as well as how people act and interact with their environment. As a former Psychology Major, I am constantly intrigued by brain chemistry, and more importantly, understanding how all of the connections in our brains influence our experience of the world overall. 

Looking at it from a psychological perspective, the emotions and feelings an employee has about their employer, manager, colleagues, role, and more is the underpinning of the employee experience. The physiological response and the release of chemicals in the brain that create feelings of excitement and connection is what organizations should strive to cultivate through their processes, programs, and practices. 

When we think about employee experience in the frame of psychology, chemicals such as dopamine, serotonin, and norepinephrine help form bonds and reshape your brain when we experience different emotions. And this happens deep in our brain with all of these chemical messengers.

We’ve all experienced this physiological response. We feel the release of dopamine when we’re engaged in our work, build and strengthen relationships with our colleagues, have meaningful metrics that tie to impactful objectives, and ultimately achieve outcomes that drive the business, and our personal and professional growth forward. 

We also know the all to familiar emotions associated with lack of clarity, the absence of positive affirmation, leading indicators of burnout, the feelings that stem from toxic work cultures, and the stress response that accompanies these critical moments or periods that negatively impact our own employee experience. 

In short, we know and sense what’s working for us and what’s not. What many of us do not tune into is the impact on our brains, and the subsequent physiological response that drives our engagement in our work and commitment to the company. 

What I strongly believe is that organizations who choose to adopt the agile performance management principles, are optimizing for creating more of the moments that lend themselves to a positive physiological response in their employees. 

‍

Key Components of Employee Experience in APM (With a Side of Psychology)

Agile Performance Management practices - such as meaningful manager-employee conversations, regular feedback, agile goal-setting, and recognition - are vital in connecting employee sentiments, initiating that positive physiological response that enhances the overall employee experience, and ultimately driving better business outcomes. With our high-level understanding of how psychology plays a role in the employee experience, let’s look at what APM means within that context. 

‍

1. Continuous Feedback and Communication

One of the fundamental aspects of APM is the emphasis on ongoing, two-way communication between employees and managers. Unlike traditional annual performance reviews, APM encourages frequent check-ins and real-time feedback. This approach allows for timely adjustments to goals, recognition of achievements, and addressing of concerns or barriers as they arise.

This continuous dialogue not only improves performance but also enhances the overall employee experience by fostering a sense of value and inclusion. And when you’ve begun to prime employees (and their brains) for a consistent cadence of feedback, they are better positioned to respond to feedback in a growth-minded way, regardless of whether it’s affirmative or constructive feedback. This is because that continuous feedback loop has made employees accustomed to receiving information, processing it, and integrating those inputs into their work and how they operate.

Understanding the neurological responses to feedback can help in creating effective communication strategies and feedback mechanisms that promote learning, motivation, and positive emotional states in workplace environments.

‍

2. Goal Alignment 

APM focuses on aligning individual goals with organizational objectives, ensuring that employees understand how their work contributes to the bigger picture. This alignment is crucial for creating a sense of purpose and meaning in one's work, which is a key driver of positive employee experience.

A study by McKinsey & Company (2020) found that employees who can see a clear link between their individual work and the company's strategic objectives are 3.5 times more likely to be engaged. This clarity not only improves performance but also enhances job satisfaction and commitment to the organization.

Additionally, the McKinsey & Company research indirectly supports the fact that brain chemistry plays a crucial role in goal alignment and clarity within the employee experience. Here's how:

First and foremost, When employees understand and align with organizational goals, their physiological response manifests itself outwardly as someone who is motivated, excited, and driven to achieve the objectives. 

The clear communication of goals naturally fosters trust between management and employees, strengthening social bonds and promoting collaboration in achieving shared goals. Furthermore, when employees feel their personal goals align with company objectives, this triggers feelings of well-being and job satisfaction. 

But this positive physiological response can’t happen in the brain without a commitment from the organization to understand and embrace how psychology influences the employee experience. 

‍

3. Clarity

As alluded to previously, a clear understanding of one’s role and responsibility as well as clarity in goals and expectations helps employees find focus and direction. Our brains naturally desire structure and a way to organize information. Clarity helps individuals prioritize what’s most important, which allows them to focus on devoting maximum effort (read: high cognitive functioning and decision-making abilities) to the most value-added activities.

Additionally, clear, achievable goals activate our brain’s executive function. This leads to better focus, prioritization, and execution of tasks aligned with organizational objectives.

By understanding these neurochemical processes, organizations can design goal-setting and communication strategies that leverage brain chemistry to enhance goal alignment and clarity, ultimately improving the overall employee experience and organizational performance.

‍

4. Flexibility and Autonomy

The Agile approach to performance management emphasizes giving employees more autonomy when it comes to the way they accomplish work. This flexibility is a crucial component of a positive employee experience, as it allows individuals to work in ways that best suit their personal preferences and circumstances.

Research by the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM, 2021) shows that 55% of employees consider flexibility to be a very important aspect of their job satisfaction. By incorporating flexibility into performance management, organizations can significantly enhance the employee experience while also improving productivity and retention.

When someone is given flexibility and autonomy in how they accomplish work, the physiological response in an individual can be observed as motivation and pleasure. As we know, that release of dopamine in the brain leads to increased engagement and satisfaction in work tasks.

APM emphasizes granting employees the freedom to approach tasks in various ways. In turn, this can stimulate the formation of new neural connections, fostering adaptability and learning. The emphasis on autonomy also reduces an employee’s stress and anxiety. This upregulation of improved cognitive function and decision-making abilities equates to better planning, problem-solving, and creative thinking.

These neurological responses can contribute to improved employee experience, increased productivity, and better overall performance.

‍

5. Personal Development and Growth Opportunities

APM places a strong emphasis on continuous learning and development. This focus on personal growth is integral to creating a positive employee experience, as it demonstrates the organization's investment in its people's long-term success.

A study by LinkedIn (2022) revealed that 94% of employees would stay at a company longer if it invested in their learning and development. By integrating personal development into the performance management process, organizations can create a more engaging and fulfilling work environment.

Similar to the effects of autonomy, development opportunities can trigger a physiological response which is associated with motivation and pleasure. This can lead to increased engagement and satisfaction in learning and growth activities.

As humans, we all have an innate desire to learn and grow. At a neurological level, learning new skills and knowledge stimulates the formation of new neural connections, fostering adaptability and cognitive flexibility. We call this enhancing neuroplasticity, which is the brain's ability to adapt and grow in response to new experiences and challenges.

And because I focus on mindset in my executive coaching practice, I can geek out on the brain’s positive response to opportunities to stretch, grow, and form these new neural connections. Engaging in personal and professional development activities stimulates the brain's executive function center, promoting better planning, problem-solving, and creative thinking.

And while learning new skills, and stretching beyond our current skills and capabilities can in and of itself be stressful, we should view that particular stress response as one that is positive and motivating in its own way. 

However, if we can view stress associated with learning as a motivator, opportunities for growth can potentially lower cortisol levels, reducing stress and anxiety. This can improve cognitive function and decision-making abilities.

These neurological responses contribute to improved employee experience, increased productivity, and better overall performance. Additionally, they can foster a sense of progress and achievement, which further reinforces positive brain chemistry and motivation.

‍

6. Recognition and Appreciation

Biologically, as humans we all desire to receive positive feedback, recognition, and appreciation for our work. Yes, many of us have been encouraged to find that recognition from within ourselves. I believe this is the byproduct of long standing assumptions that were supported by traditional performance management processes. If an organization can embrace a more people-focused (and human-centric) approach to performance management, perhaps we won’t have to pat ourselves on the back as frequently, because others are recognizing the valuable work we’re doing. 

Regular recognition of employee contributions is a key aspect of the Employee Experience principle in APM. This goes beyond formal performance evaluations to include frequent, informal acknowledgments of good work and effort.

Research by Workhuman (2023) indicates that employees who receive recognition are 4 times more likely to be engaged and 2 times less likely to leave their organization. By incorporating recognition into the fabric of performance management, APM enhances both employee experience and retention. The latter byproduct is hugely beneficial for organizations because it means they don’t have to manage the change of resignations, spend time and money hiring for backfills, and risk not achieving their objectives. 

From my perspective, the recognition and appreciation component of the employee experience is the culmination and maximizer of a positive employee experience. Get ready for brain science!

Think about what happens when you receive recognition or praise for a job well done. When you or an individual receives appreciation for their hard work, several neurological processes occur in the brain:

Recognition triggers the release of dopamine, the "reward" neurotransmitter. This leads to feelings of pleasure and satisfaction, reinforcing the behavior that led to the recognition. Appreciation also stimulates the brain's reward system in terms of increasing motivation and encouraging individuals to continue performing well.

Then we have the additional positive physiological response wherein recognition can potentially lower cortisol levels, reducing stress and anxiety, similar to the effects of having development opportunities. What’s more is that when our brain isn’t busy initiating a negative stress response to an external stressor such as a toxic work environment, we can actually be more receptive to recognition and appreciation. Our mood is elevated, we have a greater neuroplasticity to form and strengthen neural pathways associated with the recognized behaviors. In short, we become even more conditioned to exhibit the positive behaviors and have greater awareness of how we are operating. 

These neurological responses contribute to improved employee experience, increased engagement, and reinforce positive behaviors in the workplace

‍

Impact of Employee Experience on Organizational Performance

As you can see, the emphasis on Employee Experience in Agile Performance Management has far-reaching implications for organizational performance. But don’t just take my word for it!

Several studies have demonstrated the positive correlation between a focus on employee experience and various business outcomes:

‍

1. Increased Productivity

A study by IBM and Globoforce (2018) found that organizations that score in the top 25% on employee experience report nearly 3 times the return on assets compared to organizations in the bottom quartile. This suggests that prioritizing employee experience can lead to significant improvements in organizational productivity and efficiency.

‍

2. Enhanced Customer Satisfaction

Research by Temkin Group (2020) revealed a strong correlation between employee engagement and customer experience. Companies with highly engaged employees outperform their competitors by 147% in earnings per share. This indicates that a positive employee experience can translate into better customer interactions and outcomes.

‍

3. Improved Innovation

A study by Gartner (2021) found that organizations that prioritize employee experience are 3.7 times more likely to report high levels of innovation. This suggests that creating a positive work environment through APM can foster creativity and drive organizational innovation.

‍

4. Reduced Turnover

According to a study by Jacob Morgan (2022), companies that invest in employee experience see 4 times lower turnover rates compared to those that don't. This reduction in turnover can lead to significant cost savings and improved organizational stability.

‍

5. Higher Profitability

Research by Gallup (2023) indicates that companies with highly engaged workforces are 21% more profitable than those with low engagement levels. This demonstrates the direct link between employee experience and financial performance.

‍

Challenges in Implementing Employee Experience-Focused APM

‍

While the benefits of prioritizing Employee Experience in Agile Performance Management are clear, organizations often face challenges in implementation:

‍

1. Cultural Shift

Transitioning from traditional performance management to an agile, employee-centric approach requires a significant cultural shift. Many organizations struggle to overcome ingrained practices and mindsets.

‍

2. Manager Readiness

Managers play a crucial role in shaping employee experience. However, not all managers are equipped with the skills necessary to provide frequent feedback, coaching, and hold employee development conversations.3. Technology Integration

Implementing APM often requires new tools and technologies to facilitate continuous feedback and goal tracking. Integrating these systems and ensuring adoption can be challenging.

4. Measuring Impact

Quantifying the impact of employee experience initiatives can be difficult, making it challenging to justify investments in this area to stakeholders.

‍

5. Consistency Across the Organization

Ensuring a consistent employee experience across different departments and levels of the organization can be challenging, especially in large or geographically dispersed companies.

‍

Best Practices for Enhancing Employee Experience in APM

To effectively implement the Employee Experience principle in Agile Performance Management, organizations can consider the following best practices:

‍

1. Develop a Clear Employee Experience Strategy

Organizations should create a comprehensive strategy that outlines how they will prioritize and enhance employee experience throughout the performance management process. This strategy should be aligned with the organization’s mission, vision, and core values. 

‍

2. Invest in Manager Training

Provide managers with the necessary skills and tools to effectively implement APM principles, focusing on areas such as giving feedback, coaching, and facilitating career development conversations. While it’s not the fun part of managing others, I can’t underscore the importance of also training managers in how to have difficult conversations around engagement and performance. Learning to do this from a place of empathy and curiosity is a muscle that must be built. 

‍

3. Leverage Technology

Implement user-friendly tools that support continuous feedback, goal tracking, and performance discussions. Ensure these tools integrate seamlessly with existing systems to avoid creating additional administrative burden. Many tools today offer managers and HR the ability to be more efficient with their time so they can focus on building trust through in-person interaction, driving results while providing clarity and context, and generally focusing on the value-added activities that lead to high employee engagement.

‍

4. Foster a Culture of Continuous Improvement

Organizations must operate in a growth-minded way when implementing APM principles. This means encouraging ongoing feedback and suggestions from employees on how to enhance their experience. It also means being curious about what’s working and maybe what isn’t taking hold when it comes to the shift in strategy. Being curious without judgment is key to learning and not taking failures personally. Organizations should regularly review and refine APM practices based on input from their employees and make decisions based on the data available to them. 

‍

5. Measure and Communicate Impact

Developing metrics to track the impact of employee experience initiatives on key business outcomes helps you move from making decisions based on gut feelings to a place of being data-driven. By tracking key metrics, you can identify areas for improvement and demonstrate the positive shift in employee experience as you integrate agile performance management practices and approaches. 

‍

Conclusion

The third principle of Agile Performance Management, focusing on Employee Experience, represents a significant shift in how organizations approach performance management and employee engagement. By prioritizing the holistic experience of employees throughout their journey with the organization, companies can create a more motivated, productive, and innovative workforce.

‍

As an HR and People Ops Leader, I’ve come to know that the employee experience is fundamentally rooted in the emotions and feelings an individual has towards their work environment, including their employer, manager, colleagues, and role. Therefore, an intentional employee experience is one that considers the need for psychological safety, the innate desire for employees to develop a sense of belonging, and the foundation of trust that is inherently necessary for one to do their best work. 

‍

There is an undeniably clear link between a positive employee experience and improved organizational outcomes, including increased productivity, enhanced customer satisfaction, and higher profitability. Organizations that aim to foster positive employee experiences within their processes, programs, and practices can help initiate positive psychological responses, thus cultivating a more engaged and satisfied workforce. While implementing an employee experience-focused APM approach can present challenges, the potential benefits make it a worthwhile investment for organizations seeking to thrive in today's competitive business landscape.

‍